TI Claims to Obsolete FPGAs for Embedded Apps

发布时间:2017-07-07 00:00
来源:R. Colin Johnson

Texas Instruments claims to have made the field-programmable gate array obsolete for embedded industrial applications such as servo-motor control. As the world’s largest industrial-semiconductor manufacturer, TI may be uniquely positioned to make that judgment, but that doesn’t necessarily mean FPGAs are going away.

Motor drive and control functions are the key application target for the C2000 real-time 32-bit MCUs, which offer 100-MHz (10-ns cycle time) operation, low-power (1.8-V core, 3.3-V I/O) design, and Standard Test Access Port architecture. 
(Source: TI)

The short of it is that using TI’s C2000 industrial microcontroller with its DesignDRIVE fast-current-loop software provides a 460-nanosecond current loop that can eliminate the need for FPGAs in many embedded industrial control applications. The long of it is that FPGAs still have life in other applications, and TI’s approach is not the only one that offers efficiencies over the combined use of a microcontroller and FPGA, according to Tom Hackenberg, principal analyst of embedded processors at IHS Markit.

“Energy efficiency in motors is a driver of innovation, and current-loop performance—torque response—is the fundamental [determinant] of motor drive performance,” Hackenberg said in an exclusive interview. (TI makes the case in the paper “At the heart of the matter of improving servo drive performance is the system’s current-loop or torque response performance.”) “The need to enhance this responsiveness with an FPGA would likely complicate the architecture, as the pin count will increase along with the cost and space requirements,” Hackenberg added. “The C2000 microcontroller, which is highly integrated with several on-chip features, would be a favorable solution for motor drive manufacturers.”

C2000 MCUs are C28x-based 32-bit microcontrollers with a high-performance core and application-tuned peripherals designed for real-time control applications. The math-optimized core gives designers the means to improve system efficiency, reliability, and flexibility. 
(Source: TI)

Hackenberg noted that servo drives are key to a multitude of industrial applications. “In robotics and machine tools, for instance, IHS Markit predicts substantial shipment growth of GMC [generic motion control] servo drives into these applications, with average year-to-year growth of 17.1 percent and 7.1 percent, respectively, throughout 2021,” he said. “Given all considerations, I would estimate that the C2000 is a very competitive solution that is likely to eliminate the need for additional logic in some servo applications, saving designers significant cost and effort. But it is not likely to eliminate the market for FPGAs or other configurable-logic solutions, due to the wide variety of engineering skill sets, supplier relationships, valuable existing IP, and overall device design considerations that enable a continued market for alternative competitive solutions.”

TI says the C2000 can sense feedback, process the response, and actuate control systems with minimal latency. 
(Source: TI)

TI notes that the C2000 with DesignDRIVE delivers system-on-chip functionality, thus greatly simplifying and lowering the cost of drive-control system development. Using the C2000 with the submicrosecond-current-loop software enables higher control performance and board space savings while simplifying thermal budget design, according to TI. The approach offers subcycle pulse-width modulation (PWM) and improved control-loop bandwidths–potentially tripling a given motor’s torque response, according to TI–plus it needs just 460 ns for field-oriented control processing, replacing traditional proportional integration control for greater stability at higher speeds. The free fast-current-loop software will persuade most motor control designers to nix costly FPGAs, the company argues.

“The use of the C2000 with DesignDRIVE software does seem to me to be an elegant solution for servo-motor control, and I have no reason to dispute any of its performance advantages,” Hackenberg said, adding that “a hands-on demonstration” of DesignDRIVE’s use for optimizing control of a servo motor had revealed it to be “an extremely quick and painless process.” Nonetheless, there are other considerations that might lead designers to use FPGAs, he said.

“First, many servo control applications can be handled by just a microcontroller or, for significant performance demands, an embedded microprocessor. The use of an FPGA is often only a solution to enable a single processor to control multiple servos, such as [for] multiple axes of control. There may still be designs where a single microcontroller, even one as efficient as the C2000, is insufficient for a number of servos and/or additional motor controls or additional applications. An ASIC-, ASSP-, or FGPA-based solution may be required for this level of complexity,” Hackenberg said.

“Second, many suppliers of configurable ICs such as FPGAs now offer their own configurable SoCs, which include the controller on the configurable chip, thus eliminating many of the design disadvantages highlighted by TI,” he said. “These solutions can even include multiple asymmetric processor cores to enable a real-time processor for the servo control and an applications processor for the application software, and possibly even an additional microcontroller core for sensor fusion or other application demands.

“These are often costlier solutions, so the C2000 may or may not be competitive with these solutions, depending on the advantages of the additional integration” in a given application, Hackenberg said. “While the C2000 may still win in overall efficiency, even compared to servo-application-optimized solutions, there may be cases where it is not the most optimized solution.” For instance, “there are a number of semiconductor suppliers making ASICs and ASSPs, specifically targeting servo controls, that also offer efficiencies over the combined use of a microcontroller and an FPGA.”

The C2000 Peripheral Explorer Kit gives engineers a leg up on how to use the microcontroller, providing all the hardware necessary to interact with peripherals on-board. 
(Source: TI)

Existing intellectual-property investments are another consideration. “If a designer has significant investment in optimized logic IP—often based in an FPGA or ASIC—the cost efficiencies [of TI’s C2000-based solution] may be offset by the loss of existing IP based on hardware,” Hackenberg said. Further, “the application may cost-effectively utilize the [existing] servo controller solution for other device application features, for instance an array of non-servo-related sensors such as pressure or proximity sensors for safety, that can have direct feedback to the servo controller.”

So while TI’s C2000 industrial MCU with DesignDRIVE software and fast current loop can potentially obsolete FPGAs in many or even most motor control applications, it likely cannot optimally serve all.


2022-01-06 00:00 阅读量:1772
据经济日报报道,周三(6月30日)美国最大记忆芯片厂美光(Micron)公布的本季财测高于市场预期,显示计算机与手机的资料储存半导体需求强健。美光先前预告过的出售犹他州芯片厂给德州仪器一案,将为公司带进9亿美元现金。 美光估NAND、DRAM供应吃紧至明年美光估计本季(6月到8月)营收约82亿美元,高于分析师预期的78.5亿美元;剔除特定项目调整后的每股盈余约2.3美元,分析师预期为2.17美元。美光表示,本季毛利率将在46%上下1个百分点,符合市场预期的46%。财报公布后,美光股价在盘后交易时段下跌1.7%。正常交易时段则是收涨2.5%报84.98美元。美光今年以来股价只涨13%,而费城半导体指涨幅有20%。部分投资人担心疫情期间笔电与在家工作需求带动的大笔订单,将随人们重返办公室缩减。另外,中国大陆智慧手机制造商的零件库存也有增加趋势。美光执行长梅罗塔(Sanjay Mehrotra)表示,公司所有产品需求都相当强劲。不过,马来西亚厂的供应曾受到新冠病毒疫情相关封锁措施干扰,另外因汽车厂、计算机厂等工业客户其他类别的芯片短缺,产能受限,种种情况使得存储器订单受到牵制。梅罗塔强调,美光两项主要产品的价格继续上扬中,但公司为减轻未来供应链中断风险的一些布局推高成本。他强调,整个产业的NAND和DRAM两种存储器芯片供应吃紧状态将持续到明年,让价格维持在高水平。TI宣布收购美光晶圆厂存储器大厂美光周三(30日)宣布已达成最终协议,将把犹他州Lehi的晶圆厂出售给德州仪器,预估此次处分利益约15亿美元,今年下半年可望完成交易。美光表示,出售给德州仪器的记忆芯片厂位于犹他州Lehi市,是先前与英特尔合资成立的工厂。卖厂收入9亿美元现金,另有价值约6亿美元的资产,其中包含生产设备,将移往美光别的厂区或出售给其他买家。美光的Lehi厂还拥有一支具备先进半导体制造各方面专业知识的高技术团队。德仪将在收购后为所有Lehi专业团队成员提供职缺,并打算在该厂部署自家的技术,预计该交易将在今年底前完成。美光CEO Sanjay Mehrotra表示:"美光Lehi厂在技术创新和先进半导体制造方面有着悠久的历史,德州仪器是业内领导者,且重视Lehi技术团队以及该厂提供的技术部署能力。"德仪 CEO Rich Templeton则表示,Lehi厂的投资是德仪长期产能规划的一部分,预计未来该厂收购后将能提高该公司的产能。据介绍,Lehi晶圆厂将是TI的第四个300毫米晶圆厂,在TI的晶圆厂制造操作接合DMOS6,RFAB1并很快将要完成的RFAB2。除了作为 300 毫米晶圆厂的价值外,此次收购也是一项战略举措,因为Lehi将从 65 纳米和 45 纳米生产开始,用于 TI 的模拟和嵌入式处理产品,并能够根据需要超越这些节点。美光今年3月便曾有意出售Lehi厂,并计划终止3D XPoint技术的生产,为数据中心寻求新内存解决方案,专注加速CXL内存产品问世。CXL 提供运算、内存存储之间的高性能连接,能满足 AI 和数据分析的效能需求。注:图文源自网络,如有侵权请联系删除!
2021-07-01 00:00 阅读量:543
2021-02-24 00:00 阅读量:637
当地时间周四,美国一名法官表示,特朗普政府必须要在周五下午之前做出选择,要么推迟禁止美国应用商店提供短视频应用TikTok(抖音海外版)下载的禁令,要么提交法律文件在法庭上为这个决定辩护。这项禁令将于美国当地时间9月27日(周日)晚间11点59分生效,美国商务部禁止苹果和谷歌应用商店提供短视频应用TikTok下载服务。周三,TikTok向美国哥伦比亚特区地区法院提交了紧急禁令,试图阻止这一行为。美国地区法官卡尔·尼科尔斯(Carl Nichols)表示,政府必须在周五下午两点半之前对TikTok提出的初步禁令请求做出回应,或者推迟禁令生效时间。尼科尔斯法官对特朗普政府一名律师的论点提出质疑,该律师认为周日的禁令不会对TikTok造成损害。法官表示:“尽管政府提出了论点,但我不认为禁令只会维持现状,这一行动将屏蔽数十万新的TikTok用户。”尼科尔斯法官还称,如果美国政府不在周五之前自愿推迟禁令,他将在周日上午举行听证会,以决定是否授予支持TikTok的紧急禁令请求。上周六,美国商务部宣布将TikTok禁令推迟一周,理由是围绕其美国业务命运的谈判“最近取得了积极进展”。TikTok表示,这些限制“并非出于真正的国家安全考虑,而是出于与即将到来的大选相关的政治考虑。”TikTok母公司字节跳动周一宣称,将持有新成立的美国子公司TikTok Global 80%股份。甲骨文和沃尔玛已同意分别持有TikTok Global 12.5%和7.5%的股份。但甲骨文称,字节跳动所持TikTok股权将分配给其投资者,其将不会持有TikTok Global股份。同样在上周六,旧金山的一名联邦法官发布了一项初步禁令,阻止美国商务部针对微信的类似命令周日生效。商务部表示计划就此裁决上诉,但目前尚未采取行动。
2020-09-25 00:00 阅读量:559
  • 一周热料
  • 紧缺物料秒杀
型号 品牌 询价
TPIC6C595DR Texas Instruments
CD74HC4051QPWRQ1 Texas Instruments
PCA9306DCUR Texas Instruments
TL431ACLPR Texas Instruments
TXB0108PWR Texas Instruments
TPS61021ADSGR Texas Instruments
型号 品牌 抢购
TPS63050YFFR Texas Instruments
TPS61256YFFR Texas Instruments
TPS5430DDAR Texas Instruments
ULQ2003AQDRQ1 Texas Instruments
TPS61021ADSGR Texas Instruments
TXS0104EPWR Texas Instruments
AMEYA360商城(www.ameya360.com)上线于2011年,现 有超过3500家优质供应商,收录600万种产品型号数据,100 多万种元器件库存可供选购,产品覆盖MCU+存储器+电源芯 片+IGBT+MOS管+运放+射频蓝牙+传感器+电阻电容电感+ 连接器等多个领域,平台主营业务涵盖电子元器件现货销售、 BOM配单及提供产品配套资料等,为广大客户提供一站式购 销服务。